Tiger Bay
2020 Silver Tusk Awards
 •  nominee: Most Marvelous Muppet
 •  nominee: The Rockstar
 •  nominee: The Rubberface

2019 Silver Tusk Awards
 •  winner: Chameleon Award
 •  nominee: Most Utterly Ridiculous
 •  nominee: Thirst Trapper Keeper (as Clay Taylor)

2018 Silver Tusk Awards
 •  winner: Comic Genius (w/ Holly Ween)
 •  nominee: The Many Faced God/Meryl Streep Award
 •  nominee: Unconventional Conventionist
 •  nominee: Geek of All Media

2017 Silver Tusk Awards
 •  winner: Class Clown (shared w/ Fem Appeal)
 •  nominee: Rising Star

2017 Miss Coney Island
 •  winner

2016 Alternatease
 •  winner: WTF Award (for her Yeti act)

2015 New York Burlesque Festival
 •  "Huh?" Golden Pastie Award